In response to Covid-19, Cretia Cakes is only open through curbside.



The following prices are for celebration and birthday cakes only. Please contact us for wedding cake information and pricing. 

  • 1 TIER CAKES – start around $3.00 per serving with buttercream and  $4.00 per serving for fondant
  • 2 TIER (OR MORE) CAKES – start at $65.00
  • 3D CAKES – start at $150.00​

NOTE: Listed prices are baseline/starting prices for cakes. Final prices account for number of tiers, number of servings, flavors of cake, complexity of the design requested, etc.   Prices are subject to change without notice


  • Will be $25.00 and need to be paid before meeting.  The fee will go towards your cake, if you go with us.
  • Please bring other than the groom and bride, two others only (i.e. mothers of groom and bride) no children


  • Minimum custom cupcake order is a half dozen.​ 
  • The price of cupcakes start at $2.00 per serving. This does NOT include decorated cupcakes. Decorated cupcakes START at $2.50 each.


  •     Please contact us to discuss



  • Whenever possible, we like to have at least 2 months notice (more if possible) for wedding cake orders.
  • We accept cash or credit.
  • A 50% deposit is due when you place your order to secure your cake date for birthday and celebration baked goods . The final payment is due at the time of your cake pick up. (For weddings, the final payment is due two weeks prior to the wedding.)
  • When possible, we do accept last minute orders (within 1 week of the pickup/delivery date) and charge a “rush baking” fee of $5 more per 1 dozen of cupcakes and $25 more per cake. Orders of these types will be accepted or denied at our discretion.
  • Tax is 8%.
  • We book on a first come first serve basis.  Please secure your date by paying the non-refundable security deposit to secure your cake date.


  • Custom (non wedding) celebration cake delivery in the Indianapolis area is $25.00.
  • Wedding cake delivery in the Indianapolis area is $50.00; additional charge for nontraditional days and holidays.
  • Delivery always includes assembly of the cake.
  • Fees for delivery will be added to the final cost of the wedding cake. Deliveries beyond the Indianapolis area are determined based on round trip mileage.